Posts
WebMD Health News Reviewed byBrunilda Nazario, MD
Dec. 20, 2012 -- The most widely prescribed sleeping pills do help people get to sleep, but maybe not only because of the medicine, a new study suggests.
When researchers combined studies of some of the newer prescription sleep drugs, they concluded that the drugs owe about half their benefits to a placebo effect.
But at least one sleep expert disagrees with that conclusion.
Jobs That Wreck Your Sleep
Benefits Small, Study FindsThe drugs included in the study were the sleep aids Ambien, Lunesta, and Sonata and their generic versions.
The researchers conclude that these drugs improved people's ability to fall asleep compared to a placebo; however, the size of the effect was small.
They add that the risk of side effects and the potential for addiction need to be weighed when considering using these medications for treating insomnia.
Side effects of sleeping pills can include memory loss, daytime sleepiness, and increased risk of falls, and researchers say the drugs may be especially risky for older patients.
But a sleep specialist says the study does little to convince him that the drugs -- used by millions of people worldwide -- are less effective than studies suggest.
“The fact is that it is difficult to measure the effectiveness of sleep medications in studies. Patients take them and they either work or they don’t.”
“I don’t see how these researchers can come to the conclusion that 50% of the effect of these sleeping pills are due to the placebo effect,” says David Volpi, MD, of the sleep disorders division of Lenox Hill Hospital in New York.
Sleep Aid Helps Users Fall Asleep FasterThe new analysis, published in BMJ, was a collaborative effort by scientists from the University of Lincoln in the U.K., Harvard University, and the University of Connecticut.
It included data from 13 trials submitted by pharmaceutical companies to the FDA for approval of eszopiclone (Lunesta), zaleplon (Sonata), and zolpidem (Ambien).
The studies focused on the time it took to fall asleep after taking the drug.
The new analysis shows that sleeping pill users fell asleep about 22 minutes faster than non-users. Those on placebo fell asleep after 42 minutes.
According to researcher A. Niroshan Siriwardena, MD, PhD, one of the major limitations of studies submitted to the FDA is that they failed to measure some of the most troubling issues associated with sleep disturbances including total sleep time, waking after falling asleep, and daytime sleepiness.
“Because the studies didn’t measure these things, we cannot say whether these drugs are useful for improving these outcomes,” he says.
Nondrug Sleep Treatments EffectiveVolpi says prescription sleeping pills are often used by patients for much longer than they were originally intended.
These drugs are overprescribed and patients stay on them too long, he says. “It’s not unusual to see patients who have been on them for years.”
Siriwardena and Volpi also agree that other types of sleep treatments, such as talk therapy, are underutilized and could be used to help many more patients with sleep issues.
“There are so many things you can try for sleep problems, and cognitive behavioral therapy is one of the best things patients can do to get off of these medication,” Volpi says says.
The manufacturer of Ambien was contacted but declined to comment. The makers of Lunesta and Sonata were contacted but did not respond before publication.
View Article Sources
SOURCES:
Huedo-Medina, T. BMJ, Dec. 17, 2012.
A. Niroshan Siriwardena, MD, PhD, professor of primary and prehospital health care, University of Lincoln, Lincoln, U.K.
David Volpi, MD, sleep specialist, Lenox Hill Hospital’s Head and Neck Institute, Sleep Disorder’s Division, New York.
News release, University of Lincoln.
© 2012 WebMD, LLC. All rights reserved. #url_reference {display: none};#url_reference { display: block; line-height: 150%; margin-bottom: 10px; }#logo_rdr img { visibility: visible; }.titleBar_rdr .titleBarMiddle_fmt { padding-top: 1.5em !important;} Top Picks How to Handle Gout Flare-Ups Is Depression Wrecking Your Sleep? Which Pain Relivers are Best For You? Sleep Deprivation and Overactive Bladder Sleep Needs: Is Your Child Getting Enough? 13 Jobs That Can Wreck Your Sleep Sleep Disorders Home News Reference Videos Community Questions and Answers Glossary Medications
Sleep Disorders Guide 1 Good Sleep Habits 2 Sleep Problems 3 What Affects Sleep 4 Living & Managing 5 Tests & Treatments 6 Tools See what others are asking aboutVisit WebMD Answers
Related to Sleep Disorders Circadian Rhythm Dry Mouth Insomnia Living Healthy Natural Sleep Remedies Restless Legs Syndrome Sleep Apnea Snoring Teeth Grinding Track Your Sleep .isthisnormal .pane1 .last .radio_input {float:left;width:100px;}.isthisnormal .answer .level_graphic .range div {line-height:200%;}Is This Normal? Get the Facts Fast!How Many Hours Did You Sleep Last Night?My Number:NextIs that amount of sleep typical for you?YesNo, I usually get moreNo, I usually get lessDid you get enough sleep to feel alert today and function at your best?YesNoNextGet the latest Sleep Disorders newsletter delivered to your inbox! I have read and agree to WebMD's Privacy Policy.Submit and View Resultsor View ResultsAnswer:0-67-89+
Your level is currently
You say you are able to function well with fewer than seven hours of sleep. Some people say they can function on four to six hours of sleep each night, but research shows that adults who get fewer than seven hours of sleep — whether for just one night or over the course of days, weeks, or months — have more difficulty concentrating and more mood problems than people who sleep seven to nine hours.
Since you usually get too little sleep, please talk to your doctor about your sleep patterns. Poor quality sleep can affect many areas of your life and health, and your doctor may be able to help you if you have insomnia or other conditions affecting your sleep.
Sleep deprivation can have both short- and long-term consequences. Learn more about the health consequences of sleep loss. If you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep or staying asleep, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
It's not surprising you feel that you're not functioning at your best today. Some people say they can function on four to six hours of sleep each night, but research shows that adults who get fewer than seven hours of sleep — whether for just one night or over the course of days, weeks, or months — have more difficulty concentrating and more mood problems than people who sleep seven to nine hours.
Since you usually get too little sleep, please talk to your doctor about your sleep patterns. Poor quality sleep can affect many areas of your life and health, and your doctor may be able to help you if you have difficulty sleeping, have insomnia, or have other sleep disorders.
Learn more about the health consequences of sleep loss. If you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep or staying asleep, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
It's not surprising you feel that you're not functioning at your best today. Some people say they can function on four to six hours of sleep each night, but research shows that adults who get fewer than seven hours of sleep — whether for just one night or over the course of days, weeks, or months — have more difficulty concentrating and more mood problems than people who sleep seven to nine hours.
It's good that you usually do get more sleep, since sleep deprivation can have both short- and long-term consequences. Learn more about the health consequences of sleep loss. And if you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep or staying asleep, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
You say you are able to function well with fewer than seven hours of sleep. Some people say they can function on four to six hours of sleep each night, but research shows that adults who get fewer than seven hours of sleep — whether for just one night or over the course of days, weeks, or months — have more difficulty concentrating and more mood problems than people who sleep seven to nine hours.
It's good that you usually do get more sleep because sleep deprivation can have both short- and long-term consequences. Learn more about the health consequences of sleep loss. And if you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep or staying asleep, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
It's not surprising you feel that you're not functioning at your best today. Some people say they can function on four to six hours of sleep each night, but research shows that adults who get fewer than seven hours of sleep — whether for just one night or over the course of days, weeks, or months — have more difficulty concentrating and more mood problems than people who sleep seven to nine hours.
Since you usually get less sleep, please talk to your doctor about your sleep patterns. Poor quality sleep can affect many areas of your life and health, and your doctor may be able to help you if you have difficulty sleeping or have insomnia or other sleep disorders.
Learn more about the health consequences of sleep loss. If you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep or staying asleep, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
It's wonderful that you got a good night's sleep last night. Many people struggle to do so. Having a good sleep routine often is the key to getting the quality sleep night after night that your body needs for optimal health. Whether your sleep routine involves taking a warm bath, reading a book, or meditating, it's important to keep your bedtime and routine consistent every night and wake up around the same time every morning.
Click here to read more about the importance of sleep. If you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep, staying asleep, or sleeping too much, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
It's unfortunate you're not functioning at your best today. You say you had a good quantity of sleep last night, but maybe the quality of your sleep is not as good as it could be? Having a good sleep routine — including a consistent bedtime and wake time — often is the key to getting the quality sleep night after night that your body needs for optimal health. Since you usually sleep this amount, if you often aren't feeling your best, you should consider talking to your doctor. Could you have an underlying condition? Are you feeling anxious or depressed? Have you taken medication that disrupted your sleep? Do you or could you have sleep apnea? Or do you naturally require a little bit more sleep?
Although sleep is crucial for optimal health, some research suggests that sleeping too much can also have negative consequences. Learn more about sleep. If you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep, staying asleep, or sleeping too much, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
It's unfortunate you're not functioning at your best today. You say you had a good quantity of sleep last night, but maybe the quality of your sleep is not as good as it could be? Having a good sleep routine — including a consistent bedtime and wake time — often is the key to getting the quality sleep night after night that your body needs for optimal health. Since you usually sleep longer, if you often aren't feeling your best, you should consider talking to your doctor. Could you have an underlying condition? Are you feeling anxious or depressed? Have you taken medication that disrupted your sleep? Do you or could you have sleep apnea? Or do you naturally require a little bit more sleep?
Although sleep is crucial for optimal health, some research suggests that sleeping too much can also have negative consequences. Learn more about sleep. If you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep, staying asleep, or sleeping too much, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
It's wonderful that you got a good night's sleep last night. Many people struggle to do so. Having a good sleep routine often is the key to getting the quality sleep night after night that your body needs for optimal health. Whether your sleep routine involves taking a warm bath, reading a book, or meditating, it's also important to keep bedtime consistent and wake up around the same time every morning.
Although sleep is crucial for optimal health, some research suggests that sleeping too much can have negative consequences. Learn more about sleep. If you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep, staying asleep, or sleeping too much, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
It's unfortunate you're not functioning at your best today. You say you had a good quantity of sleep last night, but maybe the quality of your sleep is not as good as it could be? Having a good sleep routine — including a consistent bedtime and waking up at the same time — often is the key to getting the quality sleep night after night that your body needs for optimal health.
Since you usually get less sleep, please talk to your doctor about your sleep patterns. Poor quality sleep can affect many areas of your life and health, and your doctor may be able to help you if you have insomnia, another sleep disorder, or conditions affecting your sleep.
Learn more about the health consequences of sleep loss. If you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep or staying asleep, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
It's wonderful that you got a good night's sleep last night. Many people struggle to do so. Having a good sleep routine often is the key to getting the quality sleep night after night that your body needs for optimal health.
Since you usually get less sleep, talk to your doctor about your sleep patterns. Poor quality sleep can affect many areas of your life and health, and your doctor may be able to help you if you have insomnia or another sleep disorder or conditions affecting your sleep.
Learn more about the health consequences of sleep loss. If you're concerned about having trouble falling asleep or staying asleep, assess your risk for a sleep disorder.
Thank you for signing up for the WebMD Sleep Disorders Newsletter!You'll find tips and tricks as well as the latest news and research on Sleep Disorders.
View SourcesSOURCES:
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Effect of short sleep duration on daily activities--United States, 2005-2008. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2011; 60:239.
Carskadon, MA, Dement, WC. Normal Human Sleep: An Overview. In: Principles and Practices of Sleep Medicine, Fifth, Kryger, MH, Roth, et al. (Eds), Elsevier Saunders, St. Louis, MO 2011. p.16.
Harvard University: "Sleep, Performance, and Public Safety."
Did You Know Lifestyle ChoicesImpact Your Sleep?
Use the WebMD Sleep Tracker to track
your ZZZs over time.
Article 6 Surprising Sleep Wreckers 
Article Night Sweats Keeping You Awake? 
Article Can Herbs Help Me Sleep? 
Slideshow Always Sleepy? Causes, Fixes for Fatigue 
Quiz Dreams: How Much Do You Know? 
Article The Truth About Naps 
Article ADHD and Sleep Disorders 
Quiz Sleep and Crazy Hours on the Job 
ARTICLE Jobs That Wreck Your Sleep 
SLIDESHOW Foods That Help or Harm Your Sleep 
Slideshow Insomnia: 20 Tips for Better Sleep 
ARTICLE 10 Tips to Ease Nighttime Pain Subscribe to WebMD Newsletters WebMD Daily Women's Health Men's Health Weight Loss Wisdom I have read and agree to WebMD's Privacy Policy. Submit Sign up for more topics! WebMD Special Sections Sleep Well for Health Sleep Quiz: Do You Know Your Sleep A-to-Zzzzs? Health Solutions From Our Sponsors Vaccine Questions? Low Testosterone? Diabetes Care for Kids Birth Control for Moms Blood Sugar Control Advanced Prostate Cancer? Diagnosed With Low T? Fibromyalgia & Exercise Hearing Aid Alternative Insulin Pump Therapy Vaccines for All Ages Knee Pain Relief Depression & Adults Treating Fibromyalgia Relapsing MS Community In-depth coverage: Psoriasis Treatment on Target?|Healthy Mouth Help|RA Assessment|Living Healthy Guide|Family & Pregnancy Toolbox|Check Your Heartburn Symptoms Find us on:URAC: Accredited Health Web Site©2005-2012 WebMD, LLC. All rights reserved.
WebMD does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See additional information.
View the Original article
Enter Search Keywords. Use the arrow keys to navigate suggestions. Health A-Z 
Track your pain levels, triggers, and treatments. Set goals and get tips with our app for iPhone. Drugs & Supplements 
Drug, supplement, and vitamin information on the go. Living Healthy 
Want luxurious locks? 
Diet, Food & Fitness Weight Loss & Diet Plans Food & Recipes Fitness & Exercise 
Beauty, Balance & Love Healthy Beauty Health & Balance Sex & Relationships Oral Care 
Living Well Women's Health Men's Health Aging Well Teens 
Get every issue of WebMD the Magazine with a free subscription for your iPad. Family & Pregnancy 
Traveling abroad? 
Pregnancy Trying to Conceive First Trimester Second Trimester Third Trimester 
Parenting Newborn & Baby Children's Health Children's Vaccines Raising Fit Kids Mom's Guide to Winter Family Health 
Pets Healthy Cats Healthy Dogs 
Get parenting tips, track schedules, and create a mobile baby book. News & Experts 
Today's Top Health Headlines 
WebMD Experts & Blogs Read expert views and commentary on popular health topics. 
WebMD Communities Connect with people like you, and get expert guidance on living a healthy life. WebMD Answers 
Sign up to receive WebMD's award-winning content delivered to your inbox. My WebMD Sign In, Sign Up 
Health & Parenting Center 
Top 12 Issues 1. Children's Sleep 2. Sibling Rivalry 3. Fighting Flu 4. Parenting Tweens 5. Healthy Eating 6. HPV Vaccine 7. Kid Hearing Loss 8. Preschooler Milestones 9. ADHD Symptoms 10. Food Allergies 11. Discipline Tips 12. Potty Training 13. Emotional Development Living Healthy Centers Baby & Newborn Balance Children's Health Fitness Food & Recipes Healthy Beauty Pet Health Pregnancy Raising Fit Kids Sex & Relationships Teen Health Women's Health More Family & Parenting This Week on 
Make a Cheese Tortilla Snack! 
How Santa Stays So Jolly and Fit 
Is a Broken Heart Real? Today in Parenting 
Slideshow Does Birth Order Matter? 
Article Is Dirt Good for Kids? 
Article Got Tantrums? Talk Like a Toddler 
Slideshow 10 Steps to Fast, Easy Cleaning 
Tool Girls and Puberty: Had the Talk? 
Slideshow The Dirtiest Places Kids Will Find 
Slideshow Home Remedies for Cold and Flu 
Video What to Look for in a Pediatric Dentist 
Article How Adult Vaccines Help Protect Kids 
fitSlideshow Show Your Children How Special They Are 
Quiz Is It a Cold or the Flu? 
Slideshow What Are the Symptoms of ADHD? Subscribe to WebMD Newsletters WebMD Daily Women's Health Men's Health Weight Loss Wisdom I have read and agree to WebMD's Privacy Policy. Submit Sign up for more topics! WebMD Special Sections Top Questions About Family Health How Mom Can Stop Germs Health Solutions From Our Sponsors Vaccine Questions? Low Testosterone? Diabetes Care for Kids Birth Control for Moms Blood Sugar Control Advanced Prostate Cancer? Diagnosed With Low T? Fibromyalgia & Exercise Hearing Aid Alternative Insulin Pump Therapy Vaccines for All Ages Knee Pain Relief Depression & Adults Treating Fibromyalgia Relapsing MS Community In-depth coverage: Psoriasis Treatment on Target?|Healthy Mouth Help|RA Assessment|Living Healthy Guide|Family & Pregnancy Toolbox|Check Your Heartburn Symptoms Find us on:URAC: Accredited Health Web Site